In an intriguing display of ambition, Edgar Berlanga has recently expressed his eagerness to face Jaime Munguia as part of a strategy he believes will usher him back into contention for a rematch with Canelo Alvarez. Berlanga, with a record of 23-1 and 18 knockouts, aims not just for any showdown but for high-stakes battles that could validate his standing in the boxing world. His aspirations, however, shine a spotlight on a deeper issue: are these ambitions realistic, or are they simply pie-in-the-sky dreams founded on shaky ground?
Berlanga’s strategy hinges on three fighters: Munguia, Jermall Charlo, and Caleb Plant—names that, at first glance, spark intrigue but fail to establish a concrete pathway to glory. The notion that defeating these fighters could somehow elevate Berlanga to elite status feels less like a calculated plan and more like clutching at straws. To chase down Canelo—a figure notorious for his dominance and tactical prowess—Berlanga would need to face fighters that represent a real challenge. However, the current incumbents that he aims to conquer have track records that cast doubt on their competitiveness against a titleholder.
Questionable Competitiveness: The Opponents in Focus
Taking a closer look at Berlanga’s proposed opponents reveals an unsettling reality: none of them are currently regarded as the best in the super middleweight division. Jermall Charlo’s inactivity in the ring—having not fought in two years—raises eyebrows about his relevance and readiness. As he approaches the age of 35, the clock ticks on Charlo’s career, and it’s questionable whether a victory over him would bolster Berlanga’s resume meaningfully.
Next on the list is Jaime Munguia, who carries the scars of a recent knockout loss to Bruno Surace, as well as a defeat to Canelo that still lingers in the minds of boxing enthusiasts. His own trajectory appears to be stumbling—marked by inconsistency and failure to deliver when it matters most. The two wins and two losses in his previous fights hardly scream “elite.” Engaging Munguia could merely serve as a stepping stone, but with the stakes set for Berlanga’s title aspirations, one has to wonder if this is truly wise matchmaking.
Then there is Caleb Plant—another name that once heralded potential but has since floundered. At 32 years old and without notable victories since his loss to David Benavidez, is he the fierce competitor that Berlanga needs to cement his comeback? The scale is tipping in Plant’s favor, but not by an unassailable margin. Recently, Plant’s inability to make weight raises further questions about his discipline and commitment, issues that could come into play if Berlanga faces him.
Weighty Concerns and Unproven Abilities
Berlanga’s own struggles with weight add an additional layer of complexity to his boxing narrative. Recent fights have seen him tip the scales at weights that beg the question: is he fighting in the correct class? Visibly coming in much heavier after rehydrating was illustrated in his bout against Jonathan Gonzalez-Ortiz, where Berlanga appeared deceptively larger than a typical super middleweight. This pattern could signal underlying issues—an unhealthy relationship with weight management and preparation that may surface if and when he faces more formidable opponents.
If Berlanga indeed believes he can best Canelo in a rematch, claiming he fought the Mexican champion at a subpar 50% effectiveness due to health concerns, then the onus is on him to not just win but to dominate against these three targets. Yet, the boxing world doesn’t reward perceived excuses; it demands performance and conviction.
Market Dynamics and Future Aspirations
Berlanga’s ambition to negotiate directly with DAZN’s executives instead of traditional promoters suggests a desire to take control of his career trajectory. However, the assertion that he is looking beyond 2024 for monumental fights reveals an incessant yearning for recognition that may not materialize without the right victories. Instead of casting his sight on big paydays and lofty rematches, Berlanga would realize a greater benefit from honing his abilities against the best available competition—something he has yet to truly do.
Berlanga’s claims about crushing Canelo may echo grandiosity, but they also stem from a fighter’s deeply ingrained hope—a hope that stands here amid the realities of a sport that favors those who deliver, not just those who wish for opportunity. Until Berlanga can prove he possesses the grit to overcome meaningful challenges and build a robust legacy, his words may remain, in essence, what they are—shadowy aspirations in an unforgiving arena.
Leave a Reply